Friday, November 17, 2006

Just make sure you spell their name D-I-X-I-E C-H-I-C-K-S

Here's (here) an example of preaching to the congregation--when it's the choir that needs a sermon. Peter Cooper of The Tennessean has written an op/ed entitled, "Let's all shut up and listen--Chicks should be judged on music, not their political views." Cooper appears to reach the right conclusion in the article, even though his headline and much of his argument reflects that he absolutely will not go where the logic takes him. For example, compare the title and last line of the story with this excerpt,
It's hard to complain about the media trapping you in an enduring soap opera when you're writing new scripts for it and taping new episodes, but that's exactly what the Chicks have done. "Shut Up & Sing" documents them doing it, and the band members' personalities are engaging enough that it's possible to watch the movie and think, "What poor women," for a while and then later be struck by the inanity of so many of the circumstances depicted.
As Cooper notes, the Dixie Chicks have sold 1.5 million albums this year, so Maines & Co. seem to subscribe to the old PR saw, "I don't care what you say about me, just make sure you spell my name right."

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

The Dixie Chicks, Micheal Moore and all those that opposed the Iraqi invasion were vindicated. So were the Generals like Shinseki that Bush fired because they didn't agree with his half-assed plan. As William Buckley put it, "It didn't work".

Wisdom IS vindicated.

ned said...

Sorry, but nothing Michael Moore alleged is legit and the Dixie Chicks got into trouble for saying they were ashamed that they were from the same state as the President.

And has Shinseki said that it was wrong to invade Iraq? But that doesn't matter does it? I forgot, the current angle of attack is that Bush is incompetent, not that he lied . . . you guys make it hard to keep up!!

Anonymous said...

To say that "nothing Michael Moore alleged is legit" is classic response, indicative of the same kool-aide drinkers who have hired firms like the Lincoln Group to produce "good news" from Iraq at the cost of millions to taxpayers. One of the most respected journalists in American history put it correctly, you are in 'A STATE OF DENIAL.' Give it up.

ned said...

Uh . . . nothing Michael Moore alleged is legit.

ned said...

EllieMay, ever seen the Clinton Chronicles? You'd EAT 'EM UP!

ned said...

Here's a great excerpt from Christopher Hitchens' notorious de-barking of Michael Moore:"If Michael Moore had had his way, Slobodan Milosevic would still be the big man in a starved and tyrannical Serbia. Bosnia and Kosovo would have been cleansed and annexed. If Michael Moore had been listened to, Afghanistan would still be under Taliban rule, and Kuwait would have remained part of Iraq. And Iraq itself would still be the personal property of a psychopathic crime family, bargaining covertly with the slave state of North Korea for WMD. You might hope that a retrospective awareness of this kind would induce a little modesty. To the contrary, it is employed to pump air into one of the great sagging blimps of our sorry, mediocre, celeb-rotten culture. Rock the vote, indeed."

ned said...

Elliewade,
You appear to have a knack of missing the forest for the trees. And, sorry if the author of that article is a relative of yours, but you gotta bring better than that to prove your points. Your article's author thinks that Bush was behind 9/11? What a waste of my time.

ned said...

It was "successful" alright, even though it was deceptive, intentionally deceptive.

"Two-bit" dictators who can afford to construct even a dirty bomb and who have threatened to do so can't and shouldn't be ignored.

You are free to disagree, but the world is safer because 70% of Al Quaeda's organizational structure is either pushing up daisies or enjoying halal diet at Gitmo.

Sorry if I don't much trust your view on what is or is not a "good idea" in waging the war (v. the law enforcement exercise) on terror. And I find it ironic that you would pitch the Bill Clinton template (ignore the problem, hope it goes away and get re-elected) as acceptable. Killing ruthless enemies of America in the Middle East rather than Middle Tennessee sounds like a sound strategery to me.

ned said...

Gee, what's up with Bush not taking the advice of earnest, reasonable and patriotic people accusing him of conspiring on 9/11?