For the record, I am (and was) a strong supporter of separation of state and gambling. Accordingly, this headline caught my eye, "Harper asks forgiveness for voting for lottery." After reading the article, it's not clear to me exactly what she's asking forgiveness about.
(The City Paper). She labels refusal by some (Republicans, as made clear by the reporter) to significantly lower the criteria a "lie":
“We did not finish the peoples’ business and we failed young people because we lied to them,” Harper said. “We have said that the lottery was to help get them through school, and we have not done that."
Well, speak for yourself, Senator. But sincerely failing to accomplish something you've promised isn't a lie, and most legislators never intended to reduce the scholarship to a veritable handout for students merely managing to survive at a state university. I don't think that people who voted for the lottery had that in mind either.
Harper doesn't stop there, insinuating (if not outright charging) that legislators are
trying to keep kids from getting scholarship money by raising the standards.
“And we have tried to raise the standards so very high, standards that we probably could not meet. We are trying to raise those standards so high, and it’s just to keep the kids from getting scholarship money,” she added.
I know that several bloggers (notably from the Righter side of the ideological spectrum) (
here and
here) have sympathized with scholarship students having to maintain a 3.0 grade point average. And it is uncomfortable to note that students from higher-income families are faring better at maintaining the scholarships. But what is the objective for the scholarship program?
While Harper claims that legislators have misled students about the lottery, I'd say that she and any who share her view on this issue may have misled the voters of Tennessee.