I'm certainly no McCain shill, but this story gives me pause. The AP
(McCain Regrets Use of Term 'Tar Baby') is reporting as follows:
"Republican presidential contender John McCain on Friday used the term 'tar baby,' considered by some a racial epithet, and later said he regretted it."
I'm bothered by the term "considered by some a racial epithet."
The other day my children were trying to decide between three things, and they were using the "Eeny Meeny Miny Mo" method. I was thinking how cute they are and then remembered that
a couple years ago two black ladies filed a federal complaint against Southwest Airlines because a flight attendant had used a variation of the rhyme ending in "find a seat we gotta go." Until that newstory, I didn't know that the rhyme hadn't always included "grab a tiger by the toe." I had gone my entire life without a single racist intention, but someone, somewhere might take offense . . .
Couple questions: Does anyone believe that McCain is a racist? (I know, he's a Republican, but beyond that . . .)
Does anyone view "Songs of the South" as a racist work? (as opposed to simply reflecting social norms of the ante-bellum South?) Should my daughter not be reading the American Girl book "Addy" (about a slave girl) because it reflects the social norms (good and bad) of the ante-bellum South?
How many people use the term "tar baby" (actually, I'm not sure I've ever used it to mean "an inextricable problem") as an epithet? Sure, any word describing something that is dark or black could be used in a derogatory manner, assuming that being dark or black is a negative thing. To me it isn't.
It's interesting how
this article about the term states,
The expression . . . is also used occasionally as a derogatory term for black people (in the U.S. it refers to African-Americans; in New Zealand it refers to Maoris), or among blacks as a term for a particularly dark-skinned person.
I'm wondering how vigilant "offended people" are when the person using the term "tar baby" is from the ostensibly aggrieved group?
Update: Based on a Sean Braisted comment, I found a story about Tony Snow's use of the term in a press conference (his first!!). Then I found
this post on the matter complete with a voluminous comment section. I do not recall EVER hearing the term used in a racial/racist manner, but again, I don't think Uncle Remus should be banned. That comment section makes me wonder how "racist" the social environments were of people who have never heard the non-epithetish use of the term. Accordingly, am I going to let behind-closed-doors, bigoted whites willy nilly co-opt the language?