1. "An evangelical is a 'born again' Christian. Many folks who [were] "saved" were not Republicans before their conversion. They are not natural conservatives. They are conservatives because they are evangelical. They are not natural Republicans or conservatives. They are Republicans because their pastor told them to be essentially."While AC is correct that one's worldview typically affects their policy priorities, it is insulting to assert that folks who became Republican after becoming "Evangelical" do so "because their pastor told them to be essentially."
2. "The Republicans may talk a good game on social issues but what do they ever do really? Nothing. Republicans have had the majority for a quite a few years now and nothing substantial has come from it."As a commenter, Jay Bush, points out over at Volunteer Voters, originalist judicial appointments are perhaps the most significant return on Religious Conservatives' investment in the GOP. (As an aside, ironically, populists, democrats, etc. should be supportive of separation of powers and leaving legislating to accountable legislators.) But this comment is something I'm hearing more from those who are desperate to suppress interest among Religious Conservatives. Nice try. Most of us realize that Conservatives in our Federal gov't have hardly had a working majority over the past 6 years, and sending Ford, Jr. in Frist's place isn't going to bring us closer to seeing our policy views effectuated.
3. "Evangelicals have received nothing in exchange for their support of Republicans and they likely never will. Christians need to take in to account that politics is not spiritual activity.I'm not sure I completely understand AC's point (or that it is even understandable); is he conflating "faith" and "morals"? In any event, this is perhaps the greatest fallacy in the post.
"Faith should direct and influence a person[']s politics but it should not control it."
I believe that casting a vote and being involved in the political process is very much a spiritual activity in the sense that God cares what I do and in the sense that I ought to vote and politic in a fashion consistent with my espoused beliefs or convictions. Indeed, I view politics as a broad application of the Golden Rule and believe that as a citizen in a republican political system I have an obligation to "rule" justly, because public policy has an impact on my neighbor.
To sum up, I like the bumper sticker I saw in 2004: "Pray. Vote. Pray." I believe Christians should pray first for wisdom and character to do what's most consistent with God's character (as with many, if not most, decisions in life, I don't think we can expect God to write His will on a wall). Casting a vote is merely the most elementary form of political involvement, and we should do what we can as "rulers" in a republican form of gov't. At the end of the day, Christians should pray for God's will to be done and for us to accept whatever His will is. Above all, I think this process moves Christians toward having a clear conscience that we have done what we can and we are leaving the results to God.
Here's an interesting op/ed on this issue (from a Catholic, not "Evangelical" perspective) that I came across this evening. I like how she urges Christians to "ponder the principles that inspire our activism." Amen, sister.




